CRAFT ANALYSIS

See your novel through the eyes of Stephen King

A 0-100 score, 11 craft dimensions broken into 161 factors, quotes from your own text and a concrete revision plan. Grounded in recognized craft schools.

Dimension by dimension, the way a senior developmental editor reads.

You pay for your book, not a flat fee

HOW IT WORKS

Four steps to a full read

  1. 1

    Read chapter by chapter

    Each chapter is read on its own: strengths, problems, an editorial note with quotes from your text.

  2. 2

    Per-dimension analysis

    From the chapter reads we build a score for 11 craft dimensions, broken into factors and sub-factors.

  3. 3

    Factors with a school

    Each factor is a concrete aspect of craft grounded in a recognized school, with evidence and a fix.

  4. 4

    Score and recommendation

    Sub-factors add up to a dimension score and an overall result. The recommendation reconciles craft with your text's intent.

A SCORE YOU TUNE

The score is not a black box

Reweight dimensions and switch aspects on or off. The overall score recomputes live, so you tune the read to your vision for the book.

Overall score 70 strong
Characters 83
Structure & plot 80
Language & style 74
Dialogue 64
Pacing & scene craft 62
Ending & payoff 58

An illustrative example. In the app you recompute the whole score this way, dimension by dimension.

11 DIMENSIONS

Eleven dimensions of craft

Each dimension has its own score, an assessment and expandable factors with evidence and fixes.

Language & style

Showing over telling, sensory specifics, sentence rhythm and clean prose.

Structure & plot

Cause and effect, turning points, stakes and structural coherence.

Pacing & scene craft

Scene goal, tension, economy of time and the rhythm of action and rest.

Characters

Desire, arc, believable motivation and the depth of relationships.

Dialogue

Subtext, distinct voices, scene function and naturalness of exchange.

Point of view & distance

Consistency of narration, psychic distance and discipline of perspective.

World & setting

Grounding scenes in space, world coherence and the dosing of backstory.

Theme & meaning

What the book says under the plot, whether theme emerges from scenes or lecture.

Premise & originality

Freshness of the idea, genre promise and what sets the text apart.

Opening & hook

The first pages: promise, tension and a reason to keep reading.

Ending & payoff

Whether the ending pays off the threads it planted and lands emotionally.

WHAT YOU GET

A full report, not one number

An overall score, dimensions with evidence, a per-chapter read, a revision plan and a style profile. All with quotes from your text.

Overall score with bands

A 0-100 number and a band label, from „raw” to „publication-ready”.

Dimensions with evidence

Each dimension broken into factors, with a quote from the text and a fix.

Per-chapter read

A score, strengths and a list of fixes for each chapter on its own.

Revision plan

A prioritized list of editorial tasks with a severity level and a concrete fix.

Style profile & themes

Register, narrative mode, pacing intent and the themes of your book.

Dialogue 64

The exchanges carry the plot, but too often say outright what the scene already shows.

Evidence
Chapter 4: „I am angry at you because you forgot”, she said angrily.
HOW TO FIX IT

Cut the named feeling, keep the gesture. Let the anger play in the pause and in what she does not say.

per Browne & King, Self-Editing for Fiction Writers

Chapter 4
Strengths

The confrontation scene holds its tension and the interior details work on the mood.

To improve

The middle of the chapter summarizes what should be played out as a full scene.

Revision plan
critical

Play out the climax of chapter 4 as a full scene, not a summary.

high

Cut named emotions in dialogue, keep gesture and subtext.

medium

Firm up the antagonist's motivation in the second act.

GROUNDED IN SCHOOLS

Recognized craft schools

Every scoring factor cites a specific school of craft, not an anonymous opinion.

  • Robert McKee, Story
  • John Truby, The Anatomy of Story
  • Ursula K. Le Guin, Steering the Craft
  • Brandon Sanderson, Sanderson's Laws
  • Blake Snyder, Save the Cat!
  • Lajos Egri, The Art of Dramatic Writing
  • Janet Burroway, Writing Fiction
  • Browne & King, Self-Editing for Fiction Writers
  • Noah Lukeman, The First Five Pages
  • Donald Maass, Writing the Breakout Novel
  • John Gardner, The Art of Fiction
  • Jack Bickham, Scene & Structure
  • Dwight Swain, Techniques of the Selling Writer
  • John Yorke, Into the Woods
  • Christopher Vogler, The Writer's Journey
  • Lisa Cron, Story Genius
  • Orson Scott Card, Characters & Viewpoint
  • Stephen King, On Writing
  • Strunk & White, The Elements of Style

11 dimensions. 161 factors. The full taxonomy is open in the app.

TRANSPARENT METHOD

You see exactly what and why we score

For every aspect we show when something is off, how to fix it and which school it comes from.

Red flag

The biggest turns summarized in one sentence, while trivia gets full scenes.

Fix

Find the emotional peak of the chapter and play it out in real time: dialogue, gesture, a concrete detail.

School

Janet Burroway, Writing Fiction

THREE LANGUAGES

A read in your book's language

A Polish book gets a Polish read, an English one English, a German one German. Scores, evidence and fixes in the same language as your text.

A FAIR MODEL

You pay for your book, not a flat fee

Cost is based on the real length of your novel. Before you start you see a conservative estimate, around half the price of comparable editorial critiques.

QUESTIONS

Frequently asked questions

How is this different from proofreading or a beta read?

A proofreader fixes errors, a beta reader shares an impression. This is a whole-book craft read, dimension by dimension, with a method, evidence from the text and citations to schools of craft.

What exactly do I get?

A 0-100 score with a band, an assessment of 11 dimensions broken into factors, evidence quotes from your text, fixes, a per-chapter read and a prioritized revision plan.

What is the read based on?

On recognized schools of craft: McKee, Truby, Le Guin, Sanderson, Snyder, Egri, Burroway, Browne & King, Maass and others. Each factor cites a specific source.

What language will the read be in?

The language of your book. A Polish novel gets a Polish read, an English one English, a German one German.

What does it cost?

You pay by the real length of the book, not a flat fee. Before you start you see a conservative estimate. A larger, longer novel costs more.

Can I see an example before buying?

Yes. We have a full, ready example analysis you can read in full before you commit to your own.

See your novel through the eyes of Stephen King

Upload your novel and get a full craft read, dimension by dimension, with evidence from the text.

You pay for your book, not a flat fee